Peanut Butter Favorites Across Metro Detroit

By: Carolyn Hall | August 29, 2025
Peanut Butter Volcano chocolate cookies from Detroit Cookie Company

Photo courtesy of Detroit Cookie Company

Peanut butter isn’t just for sandwiches; it’s a star ingredient that shines in both sweet and savory creations. From indulgent desserts to unexpected savory pairings, Metro Detroit chefs are finding delicious ways to use this pantry staple. Whether you’re craving a comforting classic with a twist or a new flavor combination, you’ll find plenty of peanut butter-packed dishes in Metro Detroit.

Griffin Claw Brewing Company

2265 Crooks Road, Rochester Hills

Known for its craft beer and community atmosphere, Griffin Claw Brewing Company has built a reputation as a go-to neighborhood spot in Rochester Hills and Birmingham. With over 30 taps, in-house spirits, and a full menu, there’s no shortage of reasons to stop in. One of their most unique offerings in Rochester Hills is the Deep Fried Cornflake-crusted Peanut Butter & Jelly, a playful twist on a lunch staple that comes with a side of fries for the perfect sweet and savory combo. Served on the Happy Hour menu Tuesdays through Fridays, this sandwich is deep-fried and delicious. Paired with a cider or an ale, this is the grown-up version of a PB&J. 

Griffin Claw Brewing Company cornflake peanut butter and jelly sandwich
Photo courtesy of Griffin Claw Brewing Company

Vinsetta Garage

27799 Woodward Avenue, Berkley

trailblazer field

From soccer practice to grocery runs, the Chevy Trailblazer is designed to make your everyday outings a breeze.

Once an auto repair shop, Vinsetta Garage has transformed into a beloved Woodward Ave. spot that celebrates Detroit’s history while serving inventive eats. Their menu is filled with bold comfort food, from fries covered in cheese curds and gravy to Loaded Potato pizzas. For peanut butter fans, the Peanut Butter Icebox is a must-try. This indulgent dessert layers a chocolate crust with peanut butter mousse, chocolate glaze, whipped cream, and candied peanuts, making it as rich and satisfying as it sounds. It’s the perfect way to end a meal. 

Detroit Cookie Company

25600 Harper Avenue, St. Clair Shores

23421 Woodward Avenue, Ferndale

Detroit Cookie Company has made a name for itself with creative flavors that go far beyond your average cookie jar. Peanut butter lovers are spoiled for choice here, with options like the Ultimate PB Cookie loaded with creamy peanut butter, the PB Volcano Cookie filled with a peanut butter swirl and topped with chocolate and graham cracker crumbs, or the oversized XL Reese’s Pieces Cookie. For a sweet and salty choice, the 8 Mile Cookie is the way to go, with M&Ms, Reese Cups, and pretzels. Owner Lauren Roumayah shares, “We provide the best cookies, coffee, carbs, and memories! Each month we feature 3 new flavors, so there is always something new to try!” Good luck choosing just a few flavors the next time you’re in!

Detroit Cookie Co's Peanut Butter Volcano cookie cut in half
Photo courtesy of Detroit Cookie Company

Basement Burger Bar

1326 Brush Street, Detroit

42452 Ford Road, Canton

33316 Grand River Avenue, Farmington 

With a build-your-own concept and countless burger combinations, Basement Burger Bar is a playground for burger lovers. While their menu includes fresh salads, vegan proteins, and shareable starters, one specialty stands out for peanut butter fans: Drew’s Peanut Butter Bacon Burger. This stacked creation features a beef patty topped with bacon, cheddar cheese, onion straws, lettuce, pickles, and a house-made sweet and spicy sauce, invented by Drew himself. Marketing Manager Bridget keeps it simple: “Burgers made to order, the way you want it, the way you like it.” Pair your burger with a rotating draft, loaded tots, or even the Mac & Cheese Bacon Bites. 

Dave's Peanut Butter Burger from Basement Burger Bar
Photo courtesy of Basement Burger Bar

Rusted Crow on the Lake

569 Main Street, Belleville

Rusted Crow on the Lake pairs great food and cocktails with sweeping views of the water and live entertainment on the weekends. Their menu offers creative takes on comfort classics, and peanut butter makes a surprising appearance in their Brussels Sprout Salad. Flash-fried sprouts are tossed in a peanut butter vinaigrette with almonds, cranberries, carrots, and red onion, creating a savory yet nutty twist on a fresh favorite. Add your choice of protein or enjoy as is; this salad is unexpected but a favorite for good reason. 

From indulgent treats to one-of-a-kind savory creations, Metro Detroit is brimming with ways to enjoy peanut butter like never before. Whether you’re in the mood for a decadent dessert or a bold burger, these local spots prove that this classic nutty flavor has endless possibilities. Next time you’re craving comfort with a creative edge, you’ll know just where to go for a peanut butter fix.

RELATED STORIES